Catholic Jewelry Frequently Asked Questions

Handmade Catholic Jewelry: Frequently Asked Questions

Does my order come with a warranty?

Yes! All Catholic jewelry pieces have a 30-day warranty for any chain or clasp defects. The 30-day window begins when your order arrives. It includes extended coverage for holiday gifts. If you have an issue with any pieces beyond the 30-day period, please email us and we will work with you on a replacement. We can be reached at:

What is your return policy?

We are confident in the quality of our Catholic jewelry products and want you to feel the same way. Standard pieces can be returned/exchanged within 14 days of receipt (based on USPS timestamp date received) for a full refund. This return policy includes extended coverage for holiday gifts. Refunds are issued once the return package has been received. Shipping charges are non-refundable. We also offer a 30-day warranty on all chain or clasp defects. For returns and exchanges, please e-mail us at and our team is happy to assist.

Please note, we are currently unable to accept returns on custom pieces.

How long does shipping take?

United States

All U.S. orders come with free shipping via USPS First Class mail by default, which varies between 3-5 days in transit. You can purchase expedited shipping via USPS Priority Mail (1-3 days) at checkout for $5.


Canada orders are shipped via USPS First Class mail which requires 7-10 days in transit before delivery.


All other international orders are shipped via USPS First Class mail which requires anywhere from 7-21 days in transit before delivery (transit time varies per country).

Shipping Protection (Insurance)

For a small fee, Route Shipping Protection adds insurance to your order in case it's lost, damaged, or stolen in transit. We highly recommend this optional add-on for all orders, especially orders over $50.

To add Route Shipping Protection, click the "Shipping Protection" slider near the bottom of the cart page prior to checkout.

Please note: The shipping times listed above are calculated after the production time for your Catholic jewelry piece(s).

What is a common piece of Catholic jewelry?

There are many common pieces of Catholic jewelry. Specifically, our Catholic jewelry collection at Stella & Tide comes in a variety of styles including necklaces, earrings, chokers, rings, bracelets, and other add-ons. Our religious jewelry Catholic collection can be worn for any occasion. Whether you’re looking for unique, delicate jewelry to wear day-to-day, to mass, or Catholic baptism jewelry, we have handmade pieces for everyone.

When do you post new jewelry?

We send out new arrivals for our Catholic jewelry store to our Stella Squad email list before anyone else. If you’d like to be the first to know about our new arrivals, you can sign up with your email address at the bottom of this page, or on our subscribe page.

Do you provide Catholic jewelry wholesale options?

While we do not offer wholesale options at this time, we are always open to discussing partnership ideas. If interested, please contact us.

Do Catholics wear silver gold?

Our unique Catholic jewelry is gold-filled, which means it is a pressure-bonded layer of gold that has 100 times more gold than plated jewelry. It's durable, tarnish-resistant, and won't chip. Gold-filled is the perfect affordable alternative to solid gold jewelry. When gold-filled Catholic jewelry is cared for properly, its finish will last for years to come.

Size Guide


Click here to view our bracelet size guide.


Uncertain about your ring size? Check out our useful new Ring Sizer today! At just $3, our ring sizer is the easiest and most affordable option for getting the perfect fit on any finger.


Not sure what chain length to purchase, or interested in having multiple layering options? Try our necklace extender chain! Add a Fixed Extender Chain to any necklace from the product page before checkout, or purchase our Removable Extender Chain to swap the extender between S&T pieces.


If you're placing a gift order and can't measure (or if you're still unsure about your size), please reach out through our contact page prior to placing your order! We'd love to assist 🤓